![]() |
Health and Medical History of President George W. BushPresident #43: 2001-2009
↓
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
![]() |
---|---|---|
|
||
This style... | ... means the event occurred while President. |
---|---|
![]() tonsillectomy |
At age 5
1
|
![]() appendectomy |
In 1956
2
|
![]() "fatty cyst" |
|
![]() ![]() back surgery |
At some point, Bush has had surgery for sports-related back injuries
2.
|
![]() hemorrhoid |
Bush had a hemorrhoid during the period of his National Guard enlistment (1968-1973)
1.
Comment:
Before howling at Dr. Zebra for publicizing Presidential piles, consider: (1) "The
data are the data." The hemorrhoid is clearly documented. It is medical. Thus, there is
no reason to omit it. (2) A hemorrhoid is not always as lowly or as insignificant as you
are may think. Hemorrhoids are often associated with fiber-poor diets (as are colonic polyps,
which Bush has had). Hemorrhoids may be a sign of abnormal blood circulation in the liver (although
Bush has admitted abusing alcohol, there is no other evidence he has suffered liver complications).
Hemorrhoids can sometimes lead to severe complications: liver abscesses are rare, but severe
bleeding from hemorrhoids is less so. Because of his bleeding hemorrhoids in 1941,
Franklin Roosevelt
lost almost two-thirds of all the hemoglobin in his body.
|
![]() flight physical |
As an Air National Guard pilot, Bush would have been required to have a physical examination
each year, no later than July 31. (Flight physicals in the USAF/ANG expire on the last day
of one's birth month. Bush was born July 6.) Examinations can be accomplished as early
as 3 months before one's birth month.
Thus, when Bush was ordered on May 4, 1972 to undergo
a flight physical, this would most likely have been the routine start of the 3 month physical
exam window. On May 19, Bush asked his superiors how to "get out of coming to drill
from now through November"
3.
Flying examinations are normally given only at drill.
On August 1, Bush was grounded, in
part (?wholly) because he had failed to complete his flight physical
3.
Comment:
Failure to complete a flight physical is a serious matter in the military flying community.
Because failure grounds the pilot, the overall readiness of the flying unit decreases. Readiness
is the Air National Guard's primary mission.
|
![]() many fillings |
During the 2004 presidential campaign the White House released notes made during a dental examination
of Bush in 1973. The examination was performed at an Air National Guard base in Alabama.
The released notes showed extensive dental work and no wisdom teeth.
MORE
|
![]() blood type O |
Both of Bush's parents have O-positive blood
4a.
We can, therefore, conclude that Bush is type O, but can only say he is probably Rh-positive.
There is a chance he could be Rh-negative.
|
![]() ![]() alcohol abuse |
He has admitted problems with alcohol consumption in the remote past. The week before election
day 2000, reporters found record of an arrest ? conviction ? for driving while intoxicated
in the 1970s.
It is unclear whether the DUI mentioned above is the same as the following
incident: In late 1972 Bush took his then-16-year-old brother Marvin out drinking. On the way
home Bush ran his car over a neighbor's garbage cans. Confronted by his father, George W.
challenged elder Bush to go "mano a mano" outside
5
6.
Bush told his doctors in August 2001 that he currently abstains from alcohol. In 1999 he
released a three-page statement from doctors saying he had "totally abstained from alcohol
during the past 13 years"
2.
|
![]() cocaine use |
During his 2000 presidential campaign there were persistent questions about a history of cocaine
use. Eventually Bush denied using cocaine since 1992, then quickly extended the cocaine-free
period back to 1974 (age 28). NBC reporter David Bloom then noted "that current White
House appointees must disclose any drug use since their 18th birthday"
7.
Bush, however, refused to make a disclosure, instead admitting he'd made mistakes in the past,
and if voters didn't like that "they can go find somebody else to vote for. That's the
wonderful thing about democracy"
7.
Comment:
Dr. Zebra concludes Bush used cocaine in his 20s. (Should someone protest that there is no
smoking gun, Dr. Zebra reminds them that medicine has its own standards of proof. Consider,
for example, a 60 year old smoker with one hour of unrelenting squeezing midline chest discomfort,
plus nausea and EKG changes. That is not "an alleged heart attack," it is
a heart attack unless proven otherwise. Same thing here.) Cocaine use has clear medical
implications. For example, it is associated with elevated risk of acquiring chronic diseases,
such as viral hepatitis and sexually transmitted disease. Acutely, it can trigger cardiac or
cerebro-vascular catastrophe.
|
![]() tobacco chewing |
At least for a time in business school, he chewed tobacco
5.
(Copenhagen, apparently.)
|
![]() colonic polyps |
Discovered and removed in 1998 and 1999. See below.
|
![]() escape dive |
In 1999 Bush was jogging on a path in Austin, TX when a truck trailer overturned nearby. As
chunks of concrete and wood dumped behind him he dove for cover, scraping his right leg and
hip
8.
|
![]() ![]() ![]() physically fit |
As of August 2001
2,
Bush runs an average of three miles, four times a week, and "also routinely cross-trains
with swimming, free weights and an elliptical trainer." He reportedly runs a mile in 7
to 8 minutes. His physicians classified him in the top 2% of men his age for cardiovascular
fitness. He went 26 minutes on a treadmill test (protocol unnamed), attaining a heart rate
of 178 beats per minute
9.
Bush's resting heart rate was 43 beats/minute, and his blood pressure 118/74 mmHg. His total
cholesterol level was 170 mg/dl
2.
As of November 2003 he could lift as much as 215 pounds, but due to a torn meniscus he
has decreased his running, with a consequent increase in his per-mile time from 7 minutes to
9 minutes
10.
Comment:
While no one would ever discourage physical fitness, it is telling that all of
Bush' fitness did not prevent the development of coronary artery disease that led to
a coronary artery stent just four years after leaving office,
at the comparatively early age of 67. This may represent Bush's hard-living young
adulthood catching up with him.
|
![]() actinic keratoses |
Actinic keratoses are pre-cancerous sun-induced skin lesions. Three such lesions were removed
from Bush's face on August 4, 2001 using liquid nitrogen
2.
|
![]() height & weight |
At his August 2001 physical, Bush was supposedly 6 feet 0 inches tall, and weighed 189.75 pounds.
(Given that degree of precision in his weight, it probably represented his weight without clothes,
or perhaps with a hospital gown.) At his physical the previous year, he weighed 194.5 pounds.
His body fat was 14.5% in 2001, down from 19.94% the previous year
2.
USA Today, however, says that Bush is 5 feet, 11 and 3/4 inches tall
11
and Bush's much-discussed National Guard records list him as 5 feet 11 inches tall while in
his mid-20s.
Comment:
There is no medical reason to measure body fat to a precision of .01%, and it is probably not
even possible to do so with any known technique. Consequently, there is certainly no medical
reason to report body fat to that degree of precision, unless the aim is to enhance the President's
image of fitness by touting a body fat below 20%. Similarly, it is no stretch (pun intended)
to imagine that his height was rounded up to the more macho-sounding six feet. All this gives
a new meaning to the phrase "Spin Doctors."
|
![]() cigars |
President Bush smokes "an occasional cigar"
2.
|
![]() facial lesions |
On December 14, 2001, Bush had four noncancerous skin lesions removed from his face. The Press
learned of this only when Bush appeared before cameras with dark red spots on his face
2.
Comment:
These are most likely actinic keratoses, as were the lesions removed from
his face in August 2001, or perhaps basal cell carcinomas.
Bush's father,
George H. W. Bush,
had a similar procedure 8 months later.
|
![]() ![]() syncope |
On January 13, 2002, Bush lost consciousness while sitting on a couch in the White House, watching
a football game. His head hit the floor, resulting in an abrasion on his left cheekbone and
a small bruise on his lower lip. The incident was blamed on a combination of (a) Bush
not feeling well in previous days, and (b) an improperly eaten pretzel. Their combined
effect was to slow the President's heart. (The description suggests a vaso-vagal attack.) The
period of unconsciousness was brief
12
13.
Interestingly, his father
George H. W. Bush
also suffered a syncopal episode while President.
|
![]() colonic polyps |
Two benign colonic polyps were removed in 1998 and 1999, while Bush was governor of Texas
14.
Bush underwent follow-up colonoscopy on June 29, 2002, at Camp David. He denied signs or
symptoms of colorectal cancer, but underwent the procedure to be "super-cautious"
about his health
14.
The results of the examination were reported to be normal. Supposedly, another of the reasons
Bush underwent the procedure was "to underscore its importance for people over 50 who
are at risk"
15.
Before the 20-minute procedure, Bush invoked
section 3
of the
25th Amendment,
temporarily transferring Presidential powers to Vice President Cheney
MORE
-- the first time an official transfer of power had been made under that provision of the Constitution.
Bush commented: "I'm the first president to have done so (transferred power) under this
type of procedure and/or physical examination. I did so because we're at war"
15. Comment: It is often written that Ronald Reagan used section 3 of the 25th Amendment to transfer power to his Vice President on July 13, 1985 before undergoing surgery for colon cancer. However, Reagan did not explicitly invoke the 25th Amendement 4b. Details of the procedure were released MORE. Bush will likely undergo repeat colonoscopy in 5 years 15. |
![]() smallpox vaccine |
On the day he ordered smallpox vaccination of military members (Dec. 13, 2002), President Bush
announced: "This particular vaccine does involve a small risk of serious health considerations.
As Commander-in-Chief, I do not believe I can ask others to accept this risk unless I am willing
to do the same. Therefore I will receive the vaccine along with our military"
MORE
16.
There were no plans to immunize Bush's family
17,
staff
17,
the Cabinet
18,
or governors
18.
Bush had no ill effects from the vaccine
19,
unlike the experience of
John Adams.
Bush's public smallpox vaccination follows the example of
Harry Truman.
|
![]() Segway fall |
While holding a tennis raquet that may have impaired his coordination, Bush fell from a Segway
scooter at the family compound in Kennebunkport, ME in June 2003. He was uninjured... except
for the photographs of the event
8.
|
![]() torn meniscus |
Time Magazine reports Bush has had to curtail his workout routine in November 2003 "thanks
to a torn meniscus in his knee," but does not say which knee or how it happened
10.
X-rays and magnetic resonance imaging in December 2004 found damage in both knees; cross-training
was recommended
8.
Bush then took up mountain biking
20,
but it's unclear if he pursues this while in Washington.
|
![]() ![]() ear lobe creases and ?hair |
The picture on a November 2002 book's dust jacket clearly shows prominent creases in both of
Bush's ear lobes
21.
Comment:
The significance of ear lobe creases has been controversial. They were proposed as a marker
for increased cardiovascular risk in the 1970s. Why ear lobe creases should be associated with
arterial pathology has never been clearly explained -- a tendency to "fibrosis" has
been a common but unsatisfactory explanation. The multiple studies of ear lobe creases and
cardiovascular disease have yielded conflicting results. Most physicians place little stock
in the sign, but that does not mean it should be ignored, even in an aerobically fit man such
as Bush.
The Time Magazine cover of Dec. 1, 2003 confirms an ear lobe crease on the right and suggests
the presence of hair in the ear canal. The combination of and ear lobe crease and hair in the
ear canal has been reported as more predictive of coronary artery disease than either alone
22
23.
|
![]() cancelled physical |
Bush delayed his annual August physical examination in 2004 until after the November 2
election. His spokesman cited the heavy travel schedule associated with the campaign. Bush's
physicians were amenable to the postponement
20.
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() debate medicine |
Bush's Presidential debates with John Kerry in 2004 provided an unexpected and rich set of
potential medical observations of Bush, including eye blinking, jaw thrusting, mouth spittle,
and jacket bulging
MORE.
The significance of these observations is currently unknown, but they are recorded here should
something develop later (even decades later).
|
![]() internet hoaxes |
In July 2004, and again in July 2005, serious-sounding stories appeared on the Internet claiming
that
Dr. Richard Tubb
was medicating Bush for psychiatric difficulties. Dr. Zebra has examined these stories
and does not find them credible. For readers wanting to waste time, Google searches to find
the stories are
here
(2005) and
here
(2004). It hardly seems worth reporting that a blogger speculated in February 2004 that Bush
had had cosmetic surgery on his nose.
|
![]() bicycle falls |
Because of knee problems (see above), Bush took up bicycling for fitness. On May 22, 2004,
he fell from his mountain bike during the 16th mile of a 17-mile course. (One report says he
"sailed over the handlebars"
24.)
Aids said Bush was going fast over topsoil that had been loosened by rain. He was wearing a
helmet and mouthguard. Bush suffered "scrapes and scratches on his chin, upper lip, nose,
right hand and both knees"
8.
On July 7, 2005 Bush was bicycling fast in Scotland, about 45 minutes into his usual one-hour
ride, when his mountain bike skidded out from under him on slick pavement. Bush (and/or the
bicycle) hit a member of the local security detail. Bush was wearing a helmet. He suffered
minor scrapes and bruises of the left hand and arm.
Dr. Richard Tubb,
the President's physician, bandaged the hand, and was sent to look after the Scottish officer.
24
25
|
![]() ![]() ![]() jaw mannerism |
As Bush's presidency entered difficult times in September-October 2005, commentators noticed
the reappearance of a sterotyped jaw movement previously evident during the 2004 Presidential
campaign debates
MORE.
Most of the proposed causes are ill-informed
zebra hunting.
Instead, consider this simple recollection Bush had about the final weeks of 2002, when the
decision to invade Iraq was looming ever larger: There was a lot of stress. Yeah, I felt stressed. My jaw muscles got so tight. And it was not because I was smiling and shaking so many hands. There was a lot of tension during that last holiday season. 26aComment: It thus appears that Bush develops a certain jaw mannerism when stressed. Furthermore, like all humans, his body language changes when stressed 27 26b. |
![]() ![]() coronary stent |
Despite being "stratified to a very low coronary risk profile" during his annual
presidential physical in 2001, Bush underwent coronary stenting
on Aug. 6, 2013, at age 67 28.
Though without symptoms, an obstruction in at least one of his coronary
arteries was discovered during his annual physical the day before. The physical
included a stress test and an electrocardiogram. Those results prompted a CT
coronary angiogram (i.e. an angiogram of the coronary arteries performed
via a CT scan), and the results of that led to the stent. The procedure
was performed at Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas, Texas, as
an inpatient.
28.
The procedure was controversial in medical circles, as the benefits of
stenting in asymptomatic persons is unclear.
Comment:
That may be true in general,
but without knowing the precise coronary anatomay, it is not possible to
comment about the advisability of the procedure in an individual.
|
Before Presidency | During Presidency |
---|---|
![]() ![]() 1905 reviews
|
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.yahoo.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.time.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A48380-2004May22.html |
![]() | Comment: Accessed through usatoday.com: http://www.usatoday.com/news/politicselections/nation/president/2004-06-23-bush-kerry-cover_x.htm |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Full text: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2002/12/20021213-7.html |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.yahoo.com: http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=afp/us_vote_bush_health |
![]() | Comment: Dust jacket visible at: http://images.amazon.com/images/P/0743204735.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.guardian.co.uk: http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,1280,-5123945,00.html |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.chicagotribune.com: http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-0507070179jul07,1,4234712,print.story?coll=chi-newsnationworld-hed |
![]() |
a p.251 b p.270
|
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.washingtonpost.com: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/10/11/AR2005101101577_pf.html |
![]() |
![]() | Comment: Accessed from www.latimes.com: http://www.latimes.com/news/yahoo/la-na-rules29sep29,1,2302966.story |
![]() | Comment: http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200509/s1461447.htm |